Share
Share
How to decide what to Patent and what to keep Secret: A Strategic Guide
Intellectual property (IP) protection isn’t just a legal consideration. It is an essential part of business strategy, particularly in innovation-driven industries. Consider Apple’s journey: while they patent their device designs, they maintain their software algorithms as trade secrets. Companies face a major decision when protecting their innovations: pursue patent protection or maintain trade secrets. Both paths offer distinct advantages and challenges, significantly impacting market position, competitive advantage, and long-term business value.
One primary aspect to consider when choosing between patents and trade secrets is the degree of risk involved. If your company’s success depends on keeping certain processes private, trade secrets might be your better option. However, this comes with the risk of information leakage or reverse engineering, especially in fast-moving industries. In contrast, patents offer a limited protection period, typically 20 years, but require full public disclosure (including the best method of implementation). While this transparency might seem daunting, it provides legal certainty that trade secrets can’t match.
Time, Security and Cost Factors
The speed of bringing products to market often is the decisive factor in the patent and trade secret equation.
| Patent Route | Trade Secret Route |
| 2-3 years for approval | Immediate protection |
| Uncertain protection during the application period | Requires robust confidentiality measures |
| Strong legal protection once granted | Risk of permanent loss if disclosed |
| Very expensive | Free of Cost |
| Patent Route |
| 2-3 years for approval |
| Uncertain protection during the application period |
| Strong legal protection once granted |
| Very expensive |
| Trade Secret Route |
| Immediate protection |
| Requires robust confidentiality measures |
| Risk of permanent loss if disclosed |
| Free of Cost |
Consider Coca-Cola’s strategy—while kept as a trade secret for over a century, this strategy worked because the formula couldn’t be readily reverse-engineered through chemical analysis. On the contrary, mechanical innovations often benefit from patent protection as they are easily understood by examining the product once marketed.
How Different Industries Shape IP Decisions
Industries with rapid technology cycles, like software development or telecommunications, typically rely on trade secrets. For example, Google protects its search algorithms as trade secrets due to their constant evolution. Conversely, pharmaceutical companies like Pfizer usually opt for patent protection due to:
- Longer development cycles
- Regulatory requirements
- Substantial R&D investments needing protection
Manufacturing processes often work well as trade secrets because they’re harder to reverse engineer than end products. Tesla, for instance, patents its car designs but keeps many manufacturing innovations as trade secrets.
Why Location Matters in Global IP Protection
Intellectual property databases and patent software are essential tools for companies looking to secure patent protection in a globalized market. Patent research and patent analytics can reveal valuable insights into competitors’ activities, technological trends, and potential licensing opportunities.
IP strategies vary across various regions and legal frameworks. Patents, even though it offers substantial protection, require separate applications in each jurisdiction adding costs and complexity. While trade secrets can offer global protection without registration, enforcement mechanisms vary widely across countries. The recent EU Trade Secrets Directive has strengthened trade secret protection in Europe.
Regulatory requirements can also force your hand. Industries subject to mandatory disclosure requirements, like pharmaceuticals or certain chemical processes, might find trade secret protection impractical. Similarly, government contractors often face disclosure requirements that make patent protection the only viable option.
Cross-Border Compliance
Recent legal and legislative developments continue to influence IP decisions. For instance, the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision of Heartland LLC v. Kraft Food Groups Brands LLC (2017) changed the strategies for patent litigation by altering the venue requirements for patent lawsuits. This ruling has made it more difficult for patent holders to utilize laws to their advantage in some areas, which makes trade secrets an increasingly feasible option for firms looking to safeguard their inventions.
Furthermore, the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and its enforcers have raised awareness of the importance of diligently managing confidential data. Businesses that handle sensitive data might prefer the protection of trade secrets to patents because revealing specific details in a patent might violate data protection laws in some countries, which makes confidential information an even more crucial component of protecting intellectual assets.
In addition, developments within IP law are transforming the application of patents and trade secrets. For example, the 2018 Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) in the United States strengthened trade secrets protections and provided the federal government with jurisdiction over trade secrets theft. This law makes it more attractive for companies to use trade secrets, knowing they can now seek federal protection if their proprietary information is stolen.
What's Best for Your Business
The optimal choice between patents and trade secrets depends on your specific circumstances. Consider these key questions:
- How likely is independent discovery or reverse engineering of your innovation?
- What’s your timeline for market entry and commercialization?
- How effectively can you maintain confidentiality?
- What’s your budget for IP protection?
- What are your international market ambitions?
Sometimes, a hybrid approach works best. Core technologies might merit patent protection, while manufacturing processes and improvements remain trade secrets. This strategy can provide layered protection while maximizing business value.
Summing up
By carefully weighing these factors and staying informed about legal developments, you can make strategic IP protection choices that enhance your competitive position and support your business goals. Whether you choose patents, industrial designs, trade secrets, or a combination of all, the important thing is making an informed decision that aligns with your long-term business strategy.
At PatSeer, we recognize the critical importance of making informed decisions about patent protection. Our AI-driven patent intelligence platform is equipped with powerful analytics tools and a vast database of over 172 million global patent records, providing comprehensive insights into the IP landscape. We deliver the data and analytics necessary to assess patent quality, potential infringement issues, and market trends. PatSeer combines ease of use with powerful features to streamline your IP due diligence, maximize ROI, and keep you ahead in the innovation race.
