Is Traditional Knowledge the Missing Piece for Tomorrow’s Breakthroughs?
Share:
Traditional knowledge (TK) is often the driving force behind most indigenous economies. With a rich and diverse culture, these cultural treasures represent local communities’ knowledge, practices and ideas across areas like agriculture, medicine, art and much more. This complicated relationship between TK and the existing Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) frameworks needs to be understood properly.
Recognizing and safeguarding TK is essential not only for preserving cultural diversity but also for promoting sustainable development and equitable benefit-sharing. For more details on why this awareness is essential, read ahead.
Defining Traditional Knowledge and Its Significance
TK is vital to many local and indigenous communities’ social, spiritual, cultural and economic structures. TK refers to the knowledge systems created throughout generations within a particular community, often passed down orally, covering different areas like medicinal practices, agricultural techniques and artistic expressions.
Indigenous medicinal knowledge regarding the healing properties of specific plants has greatly influenced modern pharmaceuticals. In agriculture, TK manifests in practices like crop rotation and water management that are sustainable and environmentally friendly. However, TK faces several threats, such as exploitation for profit without benefiting the originating communities, misappropriation when used without permission or compensation, often by commercial entities and loss of value, due to the declining number of practitioners or lack of transmission to younger generations.
Existing IPR Frameworks and their Limitations
Existing IPR frameworks offer several avenues for the security of TK. However, all these intellectual property search systems are not without some shortcomings when it comes to effectively safeguarding TK.
A major concern is the shared nature of TK, which often conflicts with the individualistic ethos of traditional IPR systems. Patents, for instance, are granted to inventors or organizations. However, TK is generally held by a community. In addition, the documentation and disclosure rules of the patent registration and novelty assessment process could be difficult for TK, which is typically transferred orally and not documented in traditional forms.
At the same time, most patent analysis software and databases are not designed to consider the specifics of TK. While tools undertaking patent monitoring can provide valuable information about the latest technological developments and trends in patent databases, they often fall short when understanding and documenting the intricate aspects of TK.
Emerging Legal and Policy Approaches
To overcome these limitations, various national and international initiatives are being developed to create sui generis solutions that meet the needs of diverse communities. For instance, WIPO has a committee (WIPO Intergovernmental Committee on Intellectual Property and Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge, and Folklore) that aims to establish a fair and efficient system to protect TK.
Sui generis systems allow for communal ownership and customary laws, ensuring that communities’ rights are respected and protected. Databases, registries and documentation are essential to these systems that protect TK and facilitate access to sharing agreements.
Monitoring the utilization and application of traditional wisdom in the patent landscape worldwide helps to stop infringements. AI Patent search engines are extremely useful as they can efficiently search through vast patent databases to spot possible infringements.
Case Studies
There have been several notable case studies around TK clashing with the existing IPR frameworks. Here are some of the popular case studies:
Turmeric Patent Case
In the mid-1990s, the US Patent and Trademark Office granted a patent for how to use turmeric in wound healing, a well-known procedure in India for a long time. Indian scientists protested the patent and provided proof of turmeric’s long-standing usage. The patent was later cancelled, highlighting TK documentation’s significance in preventing misuse.
Hoodia Plant Case
In southern Africa, the San people have been using the hoodia plant for many generations because of its appetite suppression abilities. A South African research organization patented this method of use, and the San people were not initially acknowledged or paid. However, following negotiation and legal action, the benefit-sharing agreement was signed, highlighting the significance of fair arrangements protecting and rewarding holders of TK.
Community-Led Initiatives
In Australia, the Yolngu community’s decision to document their ancestral knowledge of native plants used for medicinal purposes is an excellent example of community-driven TK protection. By creating a database, they managed to shield their knowledge from being exploited and ensure they share the benefits of all commercial uses.
Protecting traditional knowledge is essential to safeguarding cultural diversity and supporting sustainable growth. Integrating sui generis structures in existing IPR frameworks could provide an equitable approach to protecting TK while allowing for innovation and commercialization.
The ultimate goal of protecting traditional knowledge is not only about preserving the past but also about helping communities to flourish in the coming years. By aligning intellectual property practices with traditional knowledge holders’ needs and values, we can build a more equitable and sustainable world in which knowledge and economic growth can coexist in harmony.
PatSeer, an AI-powered patent intelligence platform, excels in patentability searches, utilizing advanced Boolean and expert AI tools to efficiently sift through vast amounts of patent data. By identifying relevant prior art, PatSeer helps ensure that relevant patents are recognized and respected, fostering a more equitable and ethical approach to innovation.
